Off the Turkey Path: Panch Phoran Roasted Chicken

Wednesday, November 21, 2012 7 comments

I spotted frozen Butterball turkeys at our supermarket and only the fact that my oven is just a glorified toaster kept me from hauling one home for Thanksgiving. Instead, as Mr. Noodle and I give thanks on this holiday for the many blessings in our lives, we'll recall with fond nostalgia the many enormous roasted poultry of bygone feasts.

Remembrances of Turkeys Past

Wild Turkey
Panicked and confused
You ran in front of us on the trail
Distressed by the aura of less fortunate fellow fowl
Thanksgiving meals past
Clinging to us
Like Marley's chains. 
Brined Turkey
Succulent and moist
You were the best of them all
Immersed in salted spiced water per Alice Waters
Thanksgiving in Minnesota
Reminding us
Of family ties. 
Fried Turkey
Crisp and juicy
You were too dangerous to make
Submerged in a gallon of bubbling hot oil
Thanksgiving in the Carolinas
Tempting us
To risk third-degree burns. 
Porky Turkey
Tender and smoky
You were falling off the bone
Blanketed with bacon strips to keep you basted
Thanksgiving in LA
Providing us
With time to bond. 
Outsourced Turkey
Tasty and lazy
You simultaneously cost and saved a lot
Purchased along with fixins' from Whole Foods Market
Thanksgiving in Urban-Suburbia
Releasing us
From kitchen captivity. 
Desiccated Turkey
Dry and stringy
You tasted like cranberry-sauced cottonballs
Disguised as meat but in truth synthetic upholstery
Thanksgiving subpar
Parching us
With your absorbency.
Undercooked Turkey
Merciless and raw
You got revenge from beyond the gravy
Consumed at lunch and reappearing before dinner
Thanksgiving best forgotten
Purging us
Of all appetite for the rest of the day. 
Wild Turkey
Skittish and distressed
You were safe from us on that day
Amused by your antics and enthralled by autumn
Thanksgiving meals yet to come
Freeing us
To explore off the turkey path.
Bacon'd Turkey

A Tale of Two Birds and Five Spices

Thanks to my small oven and the paucity (and exorbitant price) of turkeys here in the Philippines, Mr. Noodle and I are not likely to enjoy a whole roasted turkey anytime soon. While this year is not the first time I've bypassed a big bird in favor of smaller poultry, it's a challenge to find new ways of preparing plain old chicken.

So, when I came across a fabulous-sounding recipe featuring an unfamiliar spice blend called panch phoron*, I ripped it out of my sister's magazine and tucked it away for just such a Thanksgiving Day.

Also known as Bengali five-spice, this whole seed mixture of nigella, fenugreek, cumin, fennel and black mustard is most commonly used in Bangladeshi, Bengali and other Eastern Indian cuisines. Although it is available in ground form, panch phoron is best when the intact seeds are first fried in ghee (clarified butter) or cooking oil until they pop and release their distinct flavors, after which remaining ingredients are added. It is a versatile blend used not only on poultry, meat and fish, but also vegetables, lentils and bread.

Bengali five-spice is readily available in Indian and South Asian markets, but it is also quite easy to make yourself. Simply combine equal parts of the aforementioned spices (be sure they are untoasted and whole) and store in an airtight container in a cool, dry spot.

(*Also spelled phoran or puran)

Bengali Five-Spice Roasted Chicken
from Sunset magazine

This dish had a surprisingly toasty, buttery flavor reminiscent of popcorn. It may be an odd descriptor but it was quite delicious. The yogurt marinade reduces to a nicely thick, mild-flavored sauce for the roasted potatoes and vegetables.

Speaking of flavor, a comment left on the recipe page complained of the marinade's bitter taste, leading the user to abandon the recipe completely! Perhaps she should have had more faith in the instructions, which called for at least two hours (ideally overnight) of marinating. This allows the flavors of the spices and yogurt to blend and be absorbed by the chicken and vegetables. Roasting further gentles the taste, resulting in a mild flavor with a hint of sweet spice.

My own deviation from the recipe came at the oven temperature and cooking time, and it was by fluke rather than deliberation. Mr. Noodle had an important Skype call that evening and I worried about setting off the too-sensitive [ahem] smoke detector. So, I lowered the temperature to 350˚F, even though I would have to cook it longer and forego a crisp, roasted texture.

Even at this lower temperature, however, the chicken browned very quickly, necessitating a tinfoil blanket to keep it from burning entirely. Aside from that and an additional 15 to 20 minutes of cooking time, the dish came out as well as I hoped and received Mr. Noodle's enthusiastic approval.

Click here for the complete recipe.


Vegetable oil
Panch phoron
Bay leaves
Grated fresh ginger
Minced garlic
Ground coriander
Kosher salt
Plain whole-milk yogurt
Bone-in chicken leg quarters
Bell peppers & carrots

Fry panch phoron in a skillet or frying pan until seeds pop, then reduce heat and add bay leaves, ginger, garlic, coriander and salt. Sauté until fragrant, then remove from heat and let cool. Add yogurt and blend well; let marinade cool.

In a large bow or sealable plastic bag, combine chicken, chopped peppers and carrots and cooled marinade, making sure to coat well. Refrigerate at least two hours or overnight.

Layer a baking dish with potato chunks and arrange chicken mixture on top. Bake at 450˚F (see my note above) until chicken is cooked through, potatoes and other veg are tender and all are pleasantly browned.



  • BettyAnn @Mango_Queen said...

    We just feasted on turkey this week, but your post made me hungry again! What a wonderful round up, too of different ways to do turkey. Thanks for sharing this, Tracey! I am thankful for your kindness and friendship. All the best to you & Mr. Noodle!

  • Tangled Noodle said...

    Happy Belated Turkey Day, Betty Ann! I missed having turkey this year, but then again, I don't miss the hours it takes to cook the darn thing. ;-)

    Thank you for being such a great friend! 8-)

  • Table Talk said...

    I'm pretty positive I would love this recipe off the grill as well. We have a Big Green Egg, and my husband is having fun trying new recipes---just found one for him! Hope you are enjoying the Philipines!

  • Tangled Noodle said...

    Hi Debi! Off the grill sounds fantastic and I would love to hear how it turns out if you throw this in the Big Green Egg.

    We're definitely enjoying ourselves here (especially when we hear about winter temps back in MN). One thing we do miss is our backyard grill - unfortunately, we're now condo-dwellers with only a tiny balcony. I'm sure you and your husband are having fun with that Egg! 8-)

  • ChichaJo said...

    Since it's just the two and a half of us we hardly make turkey...I think we've only actually made it ourselves once! So we rely on different versions of roast chicken :) This one sounds like a keeper! Love the sound of that spice mix!

    On another note...I still have your gift from Didi :)


Clean Template ©Copyright 2011 Tangled Noodle | TNB